NZSA Disclaimer
Paul McBeth is the editor of The Bottom Line and Curious News, and previously worked at BusinessDesk for 15 years.
Jarden’s case against its former execs is a timely reminder to check what you’re doing on your work devices.

Jarden notched up a win in the Employment Court last week, with Judge Kathryn Beck backing the investment bank’s application to sift through data cloned from the phones of former executives Dan Reynolds and Silvana Schenone.
The fact that the access was in dispute shows how far the parties were willing to go, with a King’s Counsel apiece as they battled it out in the Employment Relations Authority and the Employment Court. Those silks don’t come cheap.
In true lawyerly style, the ruling came with caveats in that Jarden can’t get its mitts on genuinely personal information, such as medical data, personal financial information, pics or the wealth of titbits shared with the ever-expanding suite of apps we all sign up for.
Legally privileged information is off-limits too.
An independent solicitor will sift through what’s in and what’s out, although one wouldn’t be overly surprised if there was a little more arguing the toss over that as well.
Yes, my loyalties turned
The early rounds were really just the phoney war before Jarden pursues more meaningful action against its defectors – who quit to join Barrenjoey’s push into New Zealand – with the investment bank claiming Reynolds and Schenone breached the firm’s policies and their contractual obligations.
As the judgment points out, after Barrenjoey’s raid snared a dozen Jarden staffers and targeted another 17, the New Zealand investment bank told its loyal employees that it was shifting from defence to offence to forcefully prosecute serious breaches of contract, statute and ethics.
Those aren’t the words of letting bygones be bygones.
There was no dispute that Jarden was entitled to its own confidential information held on the devices, but Reynolds and Schenone objected to sharing personal data willy-nilly after allegations appeared in the headlines that they believed had been leaked by Jarden, something the investment bank denied doing.
Reynolds and Schenone argued the normal discovery process was the right venue rather than what they described as a fishing expedition.
Judge Beck acknowledged their desire to protect truly private information wasn’t unreasonable but pointed out that Reynolds and Schenone were aware that Jarden’s expert should’ve been involved in cloning the information and returning the devices to their factory settings.
These precious things
Without commenting on the merits of the investment bank’s wider claim, Judge Beck said there were serious questions to be tested and that Jarden established it had an arguable case that wasn’t vexatious or frivolous.
The dispute is bound to get messier as Barrenjoey starts encroaching on New Zealand territory, and there’s a certain amount of gamesmanship going on by all parties to get the upper hand in the highly competitive world of investment banking.
Barrenjoey moved at a frenetic pace in its New Zealand foray, with the raid on Jarden staff happening alongside a separate deal with Craigs Investment Partners to absorb Craigs’ capital markets team and keep servicing the wealth arm.
Craigs’ corporate and institutional chief Justin Queale steps into the role of executive chair of Barrenjoey NZ, with Reynolds and Schenone rounding out the local leadership.
The Aussie investment firm will spend next year building its New Zealand outpost, with the business shifting up a gear in 2028 and benefits expected to start emerging the following year.
But I like the way you play
Meanwhile, Barrenjoey found common ground with former strategic partner Forsyth Barr, with the pair acting as joint lead managers in Vital Infrastructure Property Trust’s block trade of a 12% stake of Vital Healthcare Property Trust.
Having an aggressive Aussie investment banker pushing its competitors hard might not be a bad thing when the cost of capital for businesses is coming under the microscope, especially as the twin tailwinds of growing KiwiSaver balances and the upcoming generational transfer of wealth gather pace.
But one of the other questions it raises is just how reliant people have become on their employers to provide all manner of devices and services that they would’ve owned themselves in the past.
Judge Beck took a fairly dim view of Reynolds and Schenone treating Jarden’s policies as tick-box exercises, calling it an unattractive submission and noting they operated in a highly regulated industry and that Schenone is a qualified lawyer.
Can you believe that?
Perhaps they should’ve known better, but the kerfuffle over what’s on whose device is indicative of how people readily sign up to fairly onerous undertakings, with little thought to just what that might mean.
Someone doing a little work on the side to supplement their income might devise some savvy – and valuable – intellectual property that might actually be owned by their employer, depending on their contract and the way it was created. Those inhouse policies matter, and the screeds of fine print in employment contracts aren’t just to keep a firm’s lawyers busy.
If you need an example of the importance of making sure you don’t lose access to your livelihood when things sour, just look at how quickly locked-out subbies swarm onto a construction site to make sure their tools don’t end up in the hands of a liquidator when a building contractor falls over.
It might seem easier to use the company’s balance sheet to cover all those nifty gadgets and software that form the basis of a white-collar job, but the Jarden dispute shows you might want to reconsider just how much of your life you want to share with your employer.
Watch Paul McBeth and Oliver Mander discuss the dispute here:
https://vimeo.com/1248512711?fl=tl&fe=ec&share=copy
Image from Gilles Lambert on Unsplash.

